What to Consider: This mascara is water-resistant, meaning it may not be the strongest for long periods of time in wet surroundings. If you have short lashes, this lengthening powerhouse is the pick for you. In testing, it got a Learn more here perfect score for not irritating eyes and was the best at lengthening lashes in our tests. Testers loved the inky, deep pigment of this mascara, saying "this is one of the deepest blacks I have tried." According to this reviewer, it's well worth the price: "I have literally tried so many mascaras in my life. I am a pretty firm believer that drugstore mascaras are pretty good and there was never a reason to splurge on mascara...until... this one. I am blown away by how amazing this mascara is. It makes you look like you are wearing false lashes and every time I wear it I am always asked if my lashes are real! I am so impressed, trust me...try it!"